Dundee Utd 1 - 0 Heart of Midlothian

League - SPL
Saturday, November 19th, 2011, 3:00 PM at Tannadice Park
Attendance: 6,925
Referee: Willie Collum
Dundee Utd  Heart of Midlothian

Scott Robertson (24)

Team Managers
Peter Houston
Paolo Sergio

Starting Eleven
Dušan Perniš
Garry Kenneth
Paul Dixon
Robbie Neilson
Gavin Gunning
Scott Robertson
Willo Flood
John Rankin
Gary Mackay-Steven
Johnny Russell
Jon Daly
Marián Kello
Andy Webster
Marius Žaliūkas
Ryan McGowan
Rudi Skacel
Ryan Stevenson
Jamie Hamill
David Templeton
Eggert Jónsson
Adrian Mrowiec
John Sutton

Steve Banks
Barry Douglas
Seán Dillon
Keith Watson
Stuart Armstrong
Lauri Dalla Valle
Ryan Dow
Jamie MacDonald
David Obua
Mehdi Taouil
Stephen Elliott
Gordon Smith
Scott Robinson
Arvydas Novikovas

Barry Douglas for Gary Mackay-Steven (80)
Stuart Armstrong for Johnny Russell (88)
Mehdi Taouil for Adrian Mrowiec (60)
Stephen Elliott for Jamie Hamill (78)
Arvydas Novikovas for John Sutton (78)

Paul Dixon (40)
Robbie Neilson (45)
Garry Kenneth (51)
Gary Mackay-Steven (74)
Jamie Hamill (43)
Mehdi Taouil (83)

Red Cards
None. None.
Appearances & Goals To Date
Dušan Perniš (GK) 90 apps -
Garry Kenneth 179 apps7 goals
Paul Dixon 121 apps3 goals
Robbie Neilson 1 app (debut) -
Gavin Gunning 14 apps1 goal
Gary Mackay-Steven 10 apps2 goals
Scott Robertson 100 apps6 goals
John Rankin 19 apps -
Willo Flood 87 apps1 goal
Johnny Russell 57 apps14 goals
Jon Daly 133 apps46 goals
Barry Douglas (sub) 38 apps3 goals
Stuart Armstrong (sub) 20 apps -

Starting Lineup
Youngest Player:Gavin Gunning (20 years 299 days)
Oldest Player:Robbie Neilson (31 years 160 days)
Average Player Age:25 years 236 days
Domestic Players:7 (63.64 % of starting eleven)

Matchday Squad
Youngest Player:Stuart Armstrong (19 years 238 days)
Oldest Player:Steve Banks (39 years 293 days)
Average Player Age:25 years 97 days
Domestic Players:11 (61.11 % of matchday squad)

First Team Debuts
Robbie Neilson(Signed November 15th, 2011)

Scott Robertson played his 100th major competitive game for the Club.

Following a spirited performance at Ibrox a fortnight ago, Peter Houston made just a single change to his starting eleven as the hosts welcomed Hearts to Tannadice in a crunch SPL clash. Having signed on during the week until the end of the season, Robbie Neilson replaced Keith Watson at right back to make his debut against his former club. There was also a welcome return to the bench for Sean Dillon who had been missing for the previous nine weeks through injury. Having been rivals in the top half of the table for the past few seasons both clubs had experienced an inconsistent start to the season, however an entertaining match looked in prospect such was the quality on display within each line up.

The visitors pushed forward from the kick off and forced an early corner after a David Templeton shot from 16 yards was deflected over then Johnny Russell’s persistence earned a corner in response for the Tangerines as both teams looked to assert themselves on the game. Another opportunity fell to Templeton after Gavin Gunning got the wrong side of John Sutton outside the box, with the former Motherwell man laying off to the winger who curled a foot wide of the post from just outside the area. The Terrors were struggling to get going and it took until nearly a quarter of the game was played before they registered an attempt at goal, but when it came a long distance strike from John Rankin rolled tamely wide of Marian Kello’s goal. Then, and it has to be said completely out of the blue, United took a shock lead. After the defence had broken down a Hearts attack a long clearance found its way out to Jon Daly on the right flank. With no support the United captain bided his time before sending in a pinpoint cross which picked out the run of Scott Robertson who headed emphatically into the right corner leaving the Hearts goalie helpless. Templeton, who was proving to be a menace to the United backline, instigated another attack in immediate response and after the ball found Sutton in space he slotted calmly beyond Pernis, only to be correctly flagged offside ruling out his effort. Pernis had to be alert when after 33 minutes Ryan McGowan sliced a cross which diverted the ball towards target but the goalkeeper recovered well and clawed the ball away as the Edinburgh side came as close as they had done to scoring. As half time approached there were a succession of bookings as the challenges started flying in, with Dixon, Hamill and then Neilson all being shown the yellow card. The latter two offences both attracted vociferous protests for a sending off however on both occasions referee Collum called it right. A late push by United saw Daly just fail to connect with a deep Dixon cross then the same player headed over from a corner as half time came with the home side in front. The Tangerines were no doubt the happier side at half time having struggled early on before taking the lead with Robertson’s first goal since December 27th 2008 against Falkirk. From that point on they demonstrated more belief and threatened more often however Hearts, with Templeton in particular looking dangerous, were far from out of the game and a big effort would be required to keep the slender lead.

As had been the case at the start of the match it was the visitors who pressed early after the break and after Kenneth fouled Skacel just outside the box, earning himself a yellow card in the process, there was a decent opportunity from the set piece. Any worries the United faithful had at that point diminished quickly as Skacel fired high over but moments later he went much closer when he may well have netted from close range had Dixon not got in his way and blocked his effort allowing Pernis to gather. Templeton then drove into the box and shot low for Pernis to hold and Rankin again tried his luck from distance as neither side was able to control proceedings. Sutton should have done better for Hearts with an hour played, scuffing his shot at Pernis after the ball had fallen kindly for him 6 yards out before Daly then had a close range strike ruled out for offside following some positive play from Robertson, who had set up Mackay-Steven to shoot at Kello creating the rebound chance for United’s captain. Paul Dixon looked keen to hit the net for the second time in recent weeks as, having seen an earlier shot sail over, he went closer after cutting inside onto his less favoured right foot and striking from just outside the penalty area. Hearts main threat was coming from long range, and following efforts from Templeton and McGowan which never looked likely to hit the net the visitors made a double change after 77 minutes throwing on Novikovas and Elliot in an attempt to turn the game their way. As a team the Terrors stood firm as the visitors applied some pressure late on, but this was without any clear opportunities and as a result they held on for the win. It was a tough 90 minutes and it was a real team effort which was required to secure a vital 3 points. The goal itself was the one real moment of class throughout the game and for that reason the points were merited. Credit must go to both sides for playing the game in a good spirit where on other occasions some of the challenges that went in may have suffered a more negative reaction.


<< Previous Match Next Match >>
Programme cover / Team sheet